Innova
3
Three dogs:
Chihuahua, 3 years old, 4.5 pounds
Siberian Husky, 4 months old, 12 pounds and growing.
Pembroke Welsh Corgi, 2 years old, 25 pounds.
I have fed these dogs, at varying points in time and not always at the same time, the following foods: Pedigree for Small Breeds, Pedigree, Canidae, Innova, and now Orijen.
Pedigree: bought a the grocery store when it was just my Chihuahua and I was a relatively uninformed dog owner. Never really noticed anything wrong at the time - her stools were firm, and she seemed okay to me physically. Then the Husky pup came along, and she had been fed Pedigree as well. She had loose stools that would not go away. The Corgi we adopted at about the same time, and she had been feeding on Canidae, which we got in small supply from her previous owner. She seemed fine too. But I knew that I couldn't continue this hodgepodge of foods, so I started doing research on a good dog food to buy for all of them. This is when I really got into the research (the gluten scare helped this along too). Orijen immediately stood out as having the best ingredients, but it wasn't available locally and I was a little leery of shipped dog food. So I settled on Innova Adult.
Chihuahua: She appeared to do well on the food - no puking or diarrhea - but she didn't appear to like the taste or texture of the kibble. She would eat three or four, then walk away. I would have to had feed her to eat any more than that. With hand feeding, though, her energy levels did go up and her coat looked shinier. Still, what good is healthy food if your dog doesn't want to eat it?
The Sibe pup: She liked the taste just fine, but she still had pretty bad diarrhea on Innova Adult. After a few weeks, I switched her to Innova puppy, and it helped a little bit (stools with a pudding consistency). Supplemented by pumpkin, it got a little better, but I was disappointed. Her energy levels remained low on Innova Adult, but rose quite a bit on the Puppy (probaby because her diarrhea was less frequent and less liquid).
The Corgi: Appeared to do well at first, but she started to like it less and less, and started to have loose stool to boot. It got to the point where her energy level was way down, and she would only eat once a day. It was this that finally made me switch to Orijen.
You can see the results of that switch in my Orijen review. To summarize, I now feed Orijen and will for the foreseeable future.
Now, I think Innova is a very good dog food made by a very good company. It's far more available and widespread than Orijen currently. It has great ingredients and is backed by a great company (Natura). It just didn't work as well as I had hoped with my dogs. If my Chihuahua was any example, it will do good things for your dog if 1) they like to eat it and 2) it doesn't give them diarrhea. It just didn't help me.