Who???

He had less talent then the other top five when he was on American Idol. No wander his career is so tanked out. Please do something with that awful hair.

The most TALENTED & underrated performer to come off "American Idol"!! This guy can sing & has tons of charisma & the "It" factor. I hope he completes his 2nd album, a Jazz follow-up to his excellent, soulful self-titled debut.

Atrocious.

Thanks for nothing American Idol fans. This guy isn't much of an artist or musician. He's had no memorable hits.I mean he's had no hits at all. Why is he even in this category?

who? lets face his 15 minutes of fame are up. he has talent but obviously didnt have what it took for longevity.

Here's an intriguing story. Way back in early 2004, I made the following RIA post about big-haired Justin: Saw him waiting tables at TGIF. Now fast forward to Feb. 2005, I'm watching MAD TV and they did a skit about former American Idol contestants and one of the troupe-members portrayed Justin working at...you guessed it dressed up like a waiter, wearing a striped shirt, and working at TGIFs! Coincidence? I think not. I am thoroughly convinced of a conspiracy theory where comedy writers are vetting through RIA posts and claiming it as their own humor.

come on he can't sing but he can dance ok but that's it. he's done like dinner

Justin is an awsome singer and was verry popular on the show. i dont know why his album wasnt succesfull. Wish to hear him again.

he was soooooo last year well now we got some new ones he-he

He's a great singer, but I'm glad people voted to have Kelly Clarkson as their American Idol. I think he needs to do something about the hair, as well.

gay

There is no excuse for a rich guy like him to have nappy hair! I don't think he was all that great, but that song of his called Sorry wasn't really that sorry, it had a nice beat to it, but that was just about what he had going for him.

Four stars for two reasons: #1- Guarini's naturally elegant voice. Guarini's vocals have a smooth soulfulness and his lyric delivery is superb. #2- Because the CD made an attempt to step out of the American Idol box of overwrought ballads.

You wanna know the reason WHY his album tanked? CUZ HE HAS NO TALENT!!!! HE CAN'T SING AT ALL!!!!!!!!! He should've found another career. His 15 minutes of fame were up the minute Kelly Clarkson was announced the winner of AI1.

unbieleivable

Most under-rated CD on the market today.

He is a controllable lovable person as soon as you get to know what he likes and how he likes it you will do the same. He may be only the runner-up but geezz gie him some credit... he is a good singer when it comes to R & B and im sure he could do some POP with people like J Timberlake and Nick Carter!!!

I Love You Justin Guarini.... You are my American Idol 4 ever never 4 get that...... Love your biggest fan Alisha

There must have been some voting conspiracy on here at one time for this fake, horrific singer to be in the top ten. His music has no personality or quality. This can be proven by how often we see him these days. He's fallen fathoms out of the public eye.

Not in the same league as the established vocalists on this list. It takes a lot of talent to make another artist's song all your own, and he wasn't able to do that as the runner-up on American Idol's first season. He has some stage know-how, but truthfully I've been more impressed by the song stylings I've heard at local Karaoke bars. Love his Chia-Pet hair, though.

How he made it in the top 40 is beyond me....and I thought it was hilarious how fast that movie with him and Kelly Clarkson went to video so fast. They are both has beens already, and they never really even made it to begin with...

Justin Guarini's music is the best.He puts his heart and soul into singing.

Well he is certainly charming but to me he is not that great. I don't think he would have done so well if he had been on the 2003 American Idol competing with the likes of Clay, Kim, and Ruben.

Sexy man! Sexy man!

o.k but no diffrent from many other voices heard nothing which makes it specialor out standing i predict he will fade !!

I must admit I was pleasantly surprised with Justin's CD. I don't necessarily like some of the songs he got stuck with. They are a little manufactured for my taste. However, that being said, I like Unchained Melody, Sorry, Doin Things and I Saw Your Face. I enjoy how Justin really feels the song. His voice sounds much stronger than when he was on American Idol. I believe this multi-talented guy will be around for a long time.

I love Justin Guarini's voice more than I love chocolate.

I NEVER get tired of this CD! Justin just sounds better and better each time you listen. SO many good songs, it impossible to choose a favorite..... from sexy "Doin' Things" to the heartbreaking "Condition of My Heart" and cool beat of "Sorry" ..... this man has, hands down, the most SEDUCTIVE voice in the biz. WELL worth it, I'm picking up another copy on his BIRTHDAY, October 28, to thank him for all the pleasure this CD has given me. HIGHLY recommended.

I love this man, however his voice was not up to par with the likes of Miss Clarkson or Miss Gray on American Idol. He has a smooth sound, very sexy look to him and I think he can pull the love ballads very well. I do believe his voice is at its best when he is dueting with Miss Clarkson, such as on Timeless. She ads to his power.

This CD is such a harmonious, musical journey from start to finish. It is my first introduction to R&B, and I really love it. I am so glad Justin brought his stamp to Unchained Melody. I will always think of him on this song. Thinking of You is my favorite. Certain tones to his voice in this song do to me what music is supposed to do; make your spirit soar. When I first heard the emotion in Get Here, I just could not listen to the song enough times. His harmony with Kelly is beautiful. I also love Inner Child from the first Whoa to the last note. Sorry is just cool. How Will You Know makes for a relaxing background song. It's very mello. I would love to hear it at a store or restaurant. Doin' Things should be being played at clubs throughout the country. This man has longevity. With his voice he can sing anything. For people who say he shouldn't do Pop or just R&B, Justin will eventually come into his own niche and find what he's the most comfortable with. In the meantime, this gem of a CD will always be in my walkman.

Justin Guarini's CD is wonderful!! I listen to it everyday. My favorites are Sorry,Condition of My Heart,If You Wanna,and Doin' Things - but ALL the songs on his CD are great!!!!!

For a debut CD with many fans to please, I think Justin did a fine job covering all the bases. His voice is as sexy and smooth as we remember from American Idol, and he sings a variety of songs from dance tunes to pop, from ballads to R&B, from a duet to cover tunes, and even one with a latin feel. I hope his next CD will show his own style more and have more of his voice on it, without so much of the background vocals, which sometimes distract from the beauty of his voice. Even so, this has become one of my all time favorite CDs!

Great album. Good mix of mid to fast tempo songs and some of the most beautiful ballads I've heard in a long time. Justin's voice is amazing.

This is a great CD that appeals to people of all ages. From my 3 year old daughter singing along to Inner Child to my 60+ mother-in-law humming along to Unchained Melody. I personally love I Saw Your Face, Sorry, If You Wanna and Condition of My Heart. Justin's voice is magical, sultry and true and you will never get tired of listening to these great songs!! Add to that the fact that he's gorgeous and gracious - and you've got the whole package. Give him a video and he'll explode on the music scene!

I was pleasantly surprised by Justin Guarini's CD. I tend to like the songs that really showcase his vocal range, Unchained Melody, Sorry and I Saw Your Face. I also enjoyed the playful Doin Things We're Not Supposed To Be Doing, If You Wanna and Condition of My Heart. Justin showed his vocal versatility, however, I do agree that some of the songs were over produced. In my opinion that is not the fault of the artist. I look forward to more music from this multi-talented artist. I would say that this is a great CD if your likes lean toward R&B.

This album is great! Justin's vocals are smooth and soulful and he shows fantastic range. There is a nice variety of catchy songs, which makes the CD easy to listen to over and over.

yeah right

You know what? I think he sucks just because I had to wade through 10 comments posted by a multiple IDer who thinks Justin is God.

Justin Guarini is the most talented male singer out there!

Grossly overrated. Not all what he's cracked up to be.

Justin Guarini's cd is incredible!I can't quit listening to it,I love every song on it.Justin projects so much emotion when he sings Condition Of My Heart and I find myself playing it over and over again.Sorry is an unusually cool song that gets your attention.I Saw Your Face and Doin Things are wonderful,but so are the rest of the songs.This is one of,if not the best CD's,that I have ever owned.

For a debut album, I was pleasantly suprised at what a great job Justin did with this album. I enjoy all the songs. Justin has a wonderful soulful voice. This album has an R& B feel which I enjoy. I look forward to purchasing future albums by this multitalented young man.

this is not music. this is a watered down prefabricated version of what the record company thinks people will buy. yes it has an even mix of up tempo songs and ballads; of course. that's what they told him he had to do. pop is not real music.

Justin Guarini's soulful voice is at it's best on his new CD. Whether it is a ballad or an upbeat hip hop song the man belts it out..it really rocks! LivinlearninlovinJustinG

Very disappointing effort from the runner up of the first American Idol. Fans will be very happy with this product, but if you never watched the show the CD is irrelevent. Rehashed R&B light and "sexy" songs used to capitalize on Mr Guarini's "charms" fail to help the singer stand apart from the handful of other male R&B light artists out there today. In order to make any impact musically he will need MUCH better material and better technical help in the studio to help camoflage where Mr Guarini's voice has been doctored. My recomendation would be to skip this and wait and see for the next CD.

I haven't taken it out of CD player since I bought it. It is my all time favorite.

Guarini's voice is smooth and elastic. The album is a captivating listen. Repeated listenings reveal new subtle nuances and the rare ability Guarini has of meaningfully delivering each song's lyrics. This debut album suggests his artistic possibilities are unlimited. Very talented guy.

This album is amazing! Justin's vocals are incredible and show the remarkable range he has!!! Justin is a phenomenal person and performer, and this album proves it!!!

Justin's debut CD is awesome. I was pleasantly surprised because I expected the CD to include more covers like on American Idol. However, there are a lot of new songs with a little for everyone. Some R&B, some pop tunes and a wonderful ballad with Kelly Clarkson. I highly recommend this CD.