David Eckstein 4

Atleast it wasn't Nomar. I like how Eckstein plays, but he is not a typical All Star selection. He makes it in the NL because there is no other good competition. Garciaparra is hurt, Renteria and Cabrera are now in the AL, and Guzman has been awful for the Nationals. If Eckstein was still in the AL, he wouldn't even be an All Star, but on the best team in the NL with little other star power to compete with, he is a decent selection.