I actually agree with you on this one...really rude people reviewing on this line of food. (I know we have our differences, but this comment was not directed at you)

Ok, why is it that in your oppinion, I am not allowed to review foods I haven't fed, but it is ok for you to? The fact is, we are allowed to review foods that we haven't tried based soley on ingredients. Because, most of the ones we wouldn't try are horrible for our pets but a lot of people don't know that. Therefor, stop being a hipocrite! Do not tell me to not right reviews on products if I haven't tried them when you do exactly the same thing.

Lol look lady. I wrote comments on 3 products and stated I did not use them, I also stated why. These are also "experiences". I did not say I did not comment on foods I did not use but that is all you seem to do, I did comment on three of them due to things the companies either stated which causes me not to use them OR things said in the thread. You keep accusing me of stalking you but you are the one that keeps attacking me....just go away lol .You have written at least 100 reviews on products you have no experience with, you write things that are incorrect and frankly do not know what you are talking about.....big difference from me making a comment that a company owner is making things up or commenting on where a food is made and defending them........later.

Wait a minute here, was it or was it not you who started "commenting" on my reviews first. This is an excerpt from one of your "comments": Please go review things you have actual experience with and stop cluttering up the site by hating every food that does not support a bunch of propaganda. How in the heck can people think it is ok for them to read about something and then mark it bad? As if they used it and it was "bad"... Very arrogant and illogical and frankly really getting on my nerves.....If you visit my profile you will notice just about even numbers on my rating and reviews because I only review things I have experience with...I dont run around the forum marking things down to boost my preferred products. People like you are ruining the purpose of this site. If you want to discuss ingredients and pet food go to a message board.....this site is about people rating products based on their experience. . . . . Do NOT accuse me of attacking you when it was you who started attacking ME! I am just defending myself. And for the record, for all of the reviews I right, I also state why I do not use them. So under your definition, that is also "experiencing" the food. IF you stop attacking me and others, then I will stop defending myself and others as well. . . .Deal?

For the record, the excerpt of Eastgsd's comment ends when I write "Do NOT accuse me of attacking..."

I am a "neutral" person here in that I haven't reviewed Abady pet food yet. I just wanted to give feedback regarding this thread. I personally come to a website such as "Rateitall" to read reviews of products by people that have actually used them. In my opinion, a rating should be based on your personal experience with a product not what you "think" about a product. I agree with what another person said - that maybe those comments belong on a message board. Since I am interested in feeding Abady food to my dog I am coming to a site such as this to read about others experience feeding Abady to their pets. I place the most weight on customer reviews of a product as they are best resource as to how their pet responds to a food. If a person hasn't actually used this product & fed Abady food to their pet than what is being written is not really a rating but rather a personal opinion of a product they have never used. I personally wouldn't think of writing a review of Abady until I actually used the product & could provide honest & helpful feedback based on personal experience. Just wanted to share my views as a member of this website.

I agree with you Dee. I say it over and over again....but I was rebuked for it and ignored. You will notice have have reviewed approx 50 some odd things and only *3* of them were based on my experience with the company rather than the product. IMO my reviews are still viable as they are experiences with the company and based on the company rather than just running down the list of foods and marking "bad" on the ones I have NO experience with and just happen to not like the ingredient panels like a large portion or posters here do. My review is based on Abady's marketing strategy and their articles....at least it was based on something. Go check out puppyloverkb's reviews....90% of them are on products she has no experience with whatsoever. Dee, I do agree with you though with the ratings left by actual consumers being the best of all. My opinion was only left as something of interest to have people maybe take a closer look at Abady marketing.