Username: Password:
Welcome! Please Sign In or Register

Jimmy Page

reviewed by Chrisrianna

Jimmy Page is best known as the guitarist for Led Zeppelin.

Chrisrianna
01/21/2008

Jimmy Page 1

He would be easily the most over-rated guitar player in the history of Rock & Roll if it wasn't for Jimi Hendrix or any other 60's guitarist..

Join to vote! 2 Helpful / 2 Funny / 0 Agree / 1 Disagree
Showing 4 Comments
You must be logged in to comment. login now.
Flick01 commented 894 days ago.
I have tried to use reason and courtesy with you but that slap at Hendrix was not necessary. If you continue to take unecessary hits at Hendrix in reviews which have nothing to do with him, you and I are going to have problems. I had gained respect for your points of view when you rewrote another post which indicated clearer thinking than your original posts which was not really a review, just an attack. Stay above the fray.

Chrisrianna commented 893 days ago.
This is not "another" slap at Jimi Hendrix. This is how I truly feel about Jimmy Page and Jimi Hendrix. I am not trying to "Piss" anyone off, nor am I looking for approval with hopes someone will agree with me. This site, I thought, was to state your opinion and leave it at that. I can not believe how upset people get over something as trivial as "Best Guitarist of All-Time". If you look at my reviews I never say anything bad about someones review, unless they call me out and I do not understand that as well. I can't believe people on this site THREATEN other reviewers for giving their opinions, because when they do that it becomes juvenile.

Flick01 commented 892 days ago.
I made no threats. When I used the phrase we would have problems it was not meant as any kind of intimidation but I would ask you to give more specific reasoning than just "over rated." Saying JP is over rated and leaving it at that, with just a reference to Hendrix doesn't tell me anything. Why is he over rated in your view? Is his speed on the frets over rated? (You can make a valid comparison to EVH as a clear justification) his style, his live performances? What is it that is over rated? His popularity? His song writing? How did you draw your conclusion? Is it just a feeling you have or are there some kind of references you can make to back it up? Bring me into your brain and walk me down the path..... and you can say the bit about Hendrix wasn't a slap but if I made a refence to EVH every time I had something negative to say about a musician you'd feel I was treating EVH unfairly and just using any negative review as a chance to hit him upside the head. Tell me more than just "he's over rated." If you have no reasons or refernces then say so, there's nothing wrong with instincts and gut feelings. I think Jimmy Buffet is over rated. He's popular, he draws huge crowds and has a big following and I can't come up with a single statistic to back up my feelings towards him but all I know is every time he comes on the radio I want tp throw up my Cheeseburger in Paradise. Walk me through your thought process. I might even see something I may have missed along the way.

2020sp commented 492 days ago.
Flick,relax. Chrisr doesn't have to justify his or her opinion to you or anyone else. He or she doesn't like the guitarists of that era. End of story.
Showing 4 Comments
About This Reviewer
By the Numbers