I really like the ingredients in merrick and think they did a great job in formulating the dry food. Their can food is another matter entirely. You would not believe the number of people who returned cans of their Wingaling because the bones were not cooked right and were actually very hard! A couple people almost had their dogs choke on the bones. Also, when I unload cases of the food, there have been multiple times where I have found the cans rotted through. There is actually mold around the lids of the cans. Believe me, it is really disgusting. And this is from cans that I order on a weakly basis! I have never had this problem with any other natural company. If it was just one or two cans that would be one thing, but I am talking about a few cans a month that are moldy like that. Again, would highly reccommend the dry food as I have never heard/seen a problem with that but would stay away from the cans.