Username: Password:
Welcome! Please Sign In or Register

Use of Torture in Interrogations of POW's

reviewed by Twitchin' Monkey

Since the photos emerged of Iraqi prisoners being mistreated at Abu Ghraib, there has been much discussion about the United States' decision to not apply the rules of the Geneva Convention ...
Read More

Twitchin' Monkey
07/03/2007

Use of Torture in Interrogations of POW's 5

  i had a professor in college who asked the opinion of the class on this issue. the situation: the government had captured a woman who had intel on a plotted terrorist attack on a hospital.  if we got info from her, hundreds would be saved, if not thousands. do you toture her for information?

the class almost unanimously said yes. and the he added: "Okay, well it comes down to you to do the torturing. no one else will do it. if you torture her, you may or may not get info. if you don't, hundreds may die when you could have prevented it. now what?"

the vote was again nearly unanimous. this time, however, it was against torture.  if you're not willing to do the torturing, then how can you vote for someone else to do it in your stead? something to think about. and i do feel that this issue is of great importance.

Join to vote! 4 Helpful / 0 Funny / 0 Agree / 0 Disagree
Showing 1 Comment
You must be logged in to comment. login now.
sadlf commented 213 days ago.
i can see your point but i do not agree, if your the only one that can do it and you refuse to that guarentees those americans will die... on the other hand if you do torture her you are at least going down swinging
Showing 1 Comment
About This Reviewer
By the Numbers