Username: Password:
Welcome! Please Sign In or Register

Agnosticism

reviewed by SilverFox

SilverFox
08/28/2007

Agnosticism 5

ORIGINAL COMMENT: Dictionary definitions of an agnostic:

(a) One who believes it is impossible to know whether there is a God;

(b) One who is skeptical about the existence of God but does not profess true atheism.

I'm an agnostic. See my comments about it here.

If yours is the only true and correct religion:

* Why are there so many other religions?

* Why do they all claim theirs is the only true and correct religion?

* Why can each point to some different "holy" writing to back their claim?

I think it's much more important to be moral than to be religious. The Golden Rule is a wonderful guiding principal. Would that more people follow it.

UPDATE: One of the final disappointing straws about religion came to me via a minister. I asked him the following: "Assume a man has lived his 80 years of life without any sin whatsoever, that he has been kind, compassionate, has worked hard and diligently, has been completely moral, and has done nothing but good works. He is a Buddhist. Can he go to heaven?"

The minister thought about it and said he would have to think further about it and give me an answer the following day. The next day when he returned his answer was "No, because the man did not believe in Jesus."

If there ever was a sillier proposition, I haven't heard it. It's the kind of thinking that gives religion a bad name. And people wonder why some of us choose not to believe in things for which we have not seen evidence (although we do remain open to seeing any evidence that might sometime appear).

Join to vote! 3 Helpful / 0 Funny / 0 Agree / 0 Disagree
Showing 9 Comments
You must be logged in to comment. login now.
Victor83 commented 825 days ago.
Yo Fox...you are an agnostic....we got it the first two times.

SilverFox commented 825 days ago.
So what is it that bothers you so much, Victor?

Victor83 commented 825 days ago.
Reposting this over and over again. But...that is your right here on RIA...so, knock yourself out.

Victor83 commented 825 days ago.
Go ask the Buddhist if the Christian who believes in Jesus can get there without achieving "Nirvana". Such a double standard!

SilverFox commented 824 days ago.
Sorry it offends you so much, Victor. I've suggested before that we ought to have a "preview" page (http://www.rateitall.com/i-976255-add-a-preview-page-for-reviews.aspx). "For reviewers like me who are troglodytes when it comes to HTML tags, I'm never sure whether a review will look like I intended until I submit it. I don't have software independent of RIA that will show text as formatted with HTML. Much of the time when I submit a review on RIA, it doesn't look at all like I intended, so I end up taking another stab at it, resubmitting it, then another stab at it, and, well, you get the picture--it may take many attempts before it is formatted the way I want it." Unfortunately not enough people supported my suggestion, so it remains an occasional frustration, not just for me, but also for you. Perhaps you have a better system.

Wiseguy commented 824 days ago.
Youre skeptical whether or not there is a God but a kook like Al Gore tells you global warming is caused by man and youre all over it. Dont waste your time trying to explain the scientific consensus, there is none.

CanadaSucks commented 824 days ago.
smart review. . .you will be hated here. . .

SilverFox commented 824 days ago.
aWiseguy--You're talking apples and oranges. There's no similarity between the two. And have you actually seen the documentary "An Inconvenient Truth"? If not, see it, and then we can talk. My brother, a conservative Republican, was as skeptical as you before he saw it. Now he's a believer. Not much point in arguing about something you haven't seen and heard for yourself.

kk6088 commented 717 days ago.
The Buddist can go to heaven if that is what he believes in, but since Buddist don't believe in going to heaven, he'll never get there, he will however go on to an after life, maybe in the form of a dove or an eagle and get as close to heaven as possible.
Showing 9 Comments
About This Reviewer
By the Numbers