Kurt Warner 5

He has 2 MVP's H reached 10,000 yards faster than anyone, 2nd to 20,000 yards. He had injuries and got a bad break out of ST Louis with his coach or he would have hall of fame yard numbers. He took the Arizona Cardinals to the SB and should have won it. He got hurt, had a coach try to tuin him, and got benched when no one else would. Even with the Giants they were in the playoff hunt. I think the biggest indicator is what the Rams have done since he left and how far the Cardinals have come. Brady is considered a hall of fame qb but he had one year where he put the numbers up. He had better teams. But looking at some of your logic he is ineligible now because he only played in one game last year. The person who said he was the worse qb to go to a sb. Well he will have the top 3 passing games in the sb.