Username: Password:
Welcome! Please Sign In or Register

Eliminate "Most Helpful Reviewers" List

reviewed by lmorovan

Quite a few people have citized this feature of RIA for isolating too many people and just being useless in general? Should it be eliminated?

lmorovan
05/06/2008

Eliminate "Most Helpful Reviewers" List 4

I suggested that all reviews be marked as anonymous so that every one can actually rate the review based on its content and not on the popularity or lack thereof of the reviewer. The original reviewer would still be credited with the review on his personal review page, and all ratings would be likewise credited. But the ratings of a review would be more objective and truthful. Of course, my suggestion was rejected, because some are here, indeed, for popularity reasons and not for the reviewing or rating. Besides, it came from me, not from a popular reviewer. Go figure.

Join to vote! 3 Helpful / 0 Funny / 0 Agree / 0 Disagree
Showing 3 Comments
You must be logged in to comment. login now.
FranksWildYears commented 565 days ago.
Would you entertain the remote possibility that the suggestion was declined on it's merit?

lmorovan commented 565 days ago.
Yes, I have thought of that too. But I made worse suggestions that were admitted to be rated by members and were accepted. Why this one is simply rejected without members having an opportunity to vote on it? It certainly reinforces the premises of my review.

FranksWildYears commented 565 days ago.
Well for one thing, this site is a business, not a democracy. For another thing, the relative merit of this suggestions compared to other's that you have made that are by your own assessment worse, is simply your opinion. A large aspect of this site, for other members anyway, is social. We wnjoy the sharing, the banter, a few laughs and from time to time a spirited difference of opinion. We keep coming back because it gives us an outlet of some type, for writing, expressing ourselves, making connections. I'm sure you are gettiing something from the site too, since you come regularly. But a lot of what you are asking for seems to me to be contrary to the social side of what people come here for. If you can't play well with others, maybe you should consider finding an outlet for your need to express yourself elsewhere. It's a big world wide web.
Showing 3 Comments
About This Reviewer
By the Numbers