Nature's Variety
3
The only 6-star rated food at dogfoodanalysis.com website without kelp or carrots (we have an allergic dog). The problem we found is the inconsistency from bag-to-bag. I think it has to do with storage time/conditions. If it goes "bad", it causes loose stools, foul-smelling stools. One of the bad bags we bought was previously-opened. The second time we had problems were with bags with dark kibbles, and lots of crumbs, as though it was the remnants of a batch. If they could get it conistently good-quality, it would be fabulous.