Username: Password:
Welcome! Please Sign In or Register

Vivisection for drug testing / medical research

reviewed by irishgit

Etymologically, vivisection refers to the dissection or, more generally, any cutting or surgery upon a living animal, typically for the purpose of physiological or pathological scientific investigation.

irishgit
11/23/2008

Vivisection for drug testing / medical research 4

Reading the comments below makes me think that there are a goodly number of folks that would like to go back to the medical conditions of the seventeenth century.  I wonder how many them would stand by and see their loved ones suffer and die because research was banned.

Join to vote! 1 Helpful / 0 Funny / 0 Agree / 0 Disagree
Showing 1 Comment
You must be logged in to comment. login now.
earthbound commented 362 days ago.
This is a tricky subject, and you have touched on a nerve, in that medical advances have been made through animal experimentation. I am not naive enough to think that that is not the case. Of course, there have been very bad red herrings (like Thalidomide), because the results seen in animals do not necessarily transfer to humans, so it is a risky business. However, the question is whether or not we have a right to do this. We are basing our right to do this on the assumption that we have the absolute right to inflict unlimited suffering on animals, based on the fact that they are not human, as opposed to based on their capacity for suffering. This I contest. I think that animal experimentation has proven to be a door to medical discovery, which was opened in the time of Descartes, when the belief was that animals did not have pineal glands, and they could not really feel pain, which has remained open, because people were reluctant to shut it, even though the foundation upon which it was based was utter hogwash. We rightly condemn experimentation on humans, although it probably would provide much more accurate pointers in medical research, based on its inhumanity. I have confidence that we as humans, in the same spirit, can turn our backs on the inhumanity of experimenting on animals, and devote our energies to finding other solutions.
Showing 1 Comment
About This Reviewer
By the Numbers