Sure Anakin won the pod race, destroyed that ship as a kid, and saved Kenobi 9 times but other than that he was kinda puss.  Obi Wan defeated him and it seemed like he didn't even want to serve the emperor but had to cuz they killed all the Jedi... ya know, nothing else to do.  He turned into Vader cuz he wanted the power to save the ones he loved from death, funny thing is that Qui-Gon Jin already figured that out.  If he would have just stayed with the Jedi and let Mace chop Palpatines head off...  So is Anakin the chosen one (he did throw the emperor over the railing) or is it Luke for facing and defeating both the emperor and Vader?