I have used Canidae for almost 2 years. I bought a new bag about 6 months ago. First I noticed they gave you less food and charged me 5 dollars more. I had not really noticed it was a new formula. Then I noticed that my dog (a Border Collie) started having gas and often bites at her rear end and produces more stool than before which tells me there are more fillers that are not digested. I am in the process of looking for a new food. I would say it is still a good food and still somewhat budget friendly if you are looking for a holistic food and cannot afford some of the other brands, many people's dogs seem to have no problem.

Unfortunately my dog is one of those who did not take to it well so now I may go to a homemade diet with some other kibble for supplement.

Remember for some it has worked others not...that is what this forum is for and all opinions should be considered. And actually I am getting a bit tired of everyone accusing everyone else of either working for Canidae or working for the competition.