just a warning- The problems you experienced with the Nature's Recipe are the same problems i experienced with Blue Buffalo. I think Blue makes a great product, it just does not seem to agree with all dogs. I had problems with the lamb puppy formula. After transitioning him to another food, his stool firmed up completely within a few days. His coat is softer, and his eyes are even brighter! I hope you have good luck with the Blue, and do not experience the same issues!