Don't care. You nerds should be discussing Tolkien, ya nerds... ya frigging nerds!

Imagine the nerve of these nerds.

Oops

What's most impressive is that he may be the only person in the history of the information super highway to put these two films on a list with Mean Girls.  Good on ya.

Well, he's a step up on me.  I can't tell the difference between them.

A little give and take here. Some thing I like about each and some I don't like about each.

I haven't seen either movie, so I don't care which one you prefer.

This I might need to take issue with. Except for the Maul vs Qui Gon/Obi-Wan fight The Phantom Menace wasn't all that great and Jar Jar had way too many lines...

I'd say Revenge of the Sith was awesome, but I keep getting reminded of those horrific little dialogue parts between Anakin and Padmé ("I love you"... "Oh, but I love you more"), as well as the little quote-spouting breaks in combat between Anakin and Obi-Wan at the end. Also, I always had a soft spot for the Phantom Menace, as it was the first Star Wars film I saw and it has good ol' Master Qui-Gon in it.