Although he might have not been the protypical QB or had the most refined traditional QB skills (in other words he was more an athlete then a classic drop back passer)  he was still an exciting player who could run a team and could find open recievers and was named to the Pro Bowl twice and might have had the greatest scrambling/running QB and perhaps the most marketable Falcon ever.  However even with the Falcon signing him to a 10 year-130 million contract in December of 2004, rumors circulated the team was thinking of parting ways with Vick if he didn't meet expectations/do something to really take the Falcons to the next level in the 2007 season. As it turns out that, they never had to make that decision as Vick's career came to a sudden halt for his role in running a dog fighting operation/gambling ring and was sent to prision. But its certainly feasible Vick could have indeed taken the team to the next level but falls short of a five star rating but with his accomplishments with the team from 2001-2006 is still very desrving of four stars.