Garmin nüvi 265WT
2
My wife and I own an inexpensive Mio DigiWalker GPS that was given to us as a gift a couple years ago, and it's done a pretty good job of getting us places, but it had it's share of glitches and errors, so I figured it was time to upgrade to a better model, the Garmin 265WT, rated as a best buy by a leading consumer magazine. I figured I'd use the new Garmin and give my wife the Mio for her car.
My first impressions of the 265WT were great--lots of features (avoid toll roads or highways if desired, for example) that the Mio didn't have. The graphics on the 265WT are outstanding, and the widescreen is much easier to read than the normal width screen on our Mio. The free FM traffic appears to work great, and the ads are not at all intrusive. Having the unit speak street names as it gives directions is also great.
But the more I put the 265WT to the test, the more I noticed the same annoying glitches that I had with my Mio. On my first attempt at navigating somewhere--to my office--the unit could not find my office address. This bothered me a little because the office complex has been there for easily more than 10 years, but still the map did not contain this data. I had expected the maps to be of higher quality and accuracy than those on the Mio.
But no big deal, I thought, and decided to take it on a trip to a furniture outlet mall about 45 minutes from home this past weekend. Once again, it failed to find this relatively old outlet mall in it's database, so we had to just set a course for the town it was in, knowing from memory that it was somewhere near the main interstate--I could have done this myself without a GPS. So needless to say I was getting a bit annoyed. And in addition to the fact that it couldn't find the places I wanted to go, it took FOREVER to show any results for my searches. With the Mio, I get search results (including if it can't find any matches) in a matter of seconds. With the Garmin, I'd type in a search and it would have an hourglass symbol on the screen for literally a minute or more--very, very frustrating. I wanted to say to it, "if you can't find what I'm looking for, fine, but at least let me know quickly so I can enter another search!"
Finally, driving in another unfamiliar area of Pennsylvania the same day, I had stopped at a convenience store and wanted to get back to the interstate. The 265WT directed me to make a few turns to circle around the store, and then, to make an ILLEGAL left-hand turn onto the main road! As if that weren't enough, it asked me to make yet another ILLEGAL left-hand turn later in the trip! Well, now I was getting seriously ticked off. These types of errors I had expected from the inexpensive Mio, but with Garmin I thought I was paying a little more for "the best." Apparently not, or apparently, the state of navigation systems is pretty sad if the consumer magazine considers this model a "best buy."
I gave the 265WT two stars because I do think it offers some great features and graphics. But for me, if the main reason you buy a GPS--THE MAPS AND THE MAP DATA--are no good, all the rest is just flimsy window dressing. So I returned mine.
Also, for some people, the sound of the navigation voice is important--I'm one of them. After all, at sometimes stressful moments of driving, you're going to be listening to this voice telling you where to turn, etc. Although the 265WT offered a few voice choices, I found both the American English male (sounds like a robot) and the American English female (sounds like a nasally woman nagging you from the back seat) to be irritating. I ended up setting the voice to an Australian English male, which I found to be the least annoying choice--but to be honest, I didn't like any of the voice choices. Our Mio has only one voice, a very average and pleasant sounding male, and I like it better than any of the choices on the Garmin. But that's just my opinion, and I'm sure to others the voices on the Garmin are just fine.
Oh well, I guess Garmin and me were not meant to be! :)
Good luck with whatever navigation system you choose!