I was fairly pleased with the list pages until I created a fairly long list. But if you are trying to rate items on a really long list, the current system is very cumbersome. The list page is in bad need of a view all button, or at bare minimum an ability to remember that you were on page 3 of 6 when you hit the back button. My "Best Athletes To Wear Nos. 1-44" list is six pages long, and is a real pain to rate right now.

UPDATE: A much needed improvement has been added that has caused me to increase my rating of the list page from two stars up to four stars. When rating long lists, if the list has six pages, then it really has six pages, meaning if you went from page 1 to page 2 to page 3, and then hit the back button twice, you'd be on page one. It also means that once you've rated something or just read the reviews under an item, and you hit back to go back the list, you'd be back to the page you started on. This improvement has happened without much fanfare around here, but in my opinion this is one of the biggest of the recent fixes to V3. Now if the "view all" option was restored, I could give the list page a five star rating.

I like the fact that we can now rate and write our reviews on the list pages instead of going into the item pages, although I've already discovered that it's quite easy to make mistakes by putting the reviews into the wrong list item.

I also don't like the new view more button to review more items on a list. I prefer not to see the items I've already gone through the first time, so the length of the list doesn't really help me. Also, I like the V2 feature where you can just choose how many items you want to see on one page and the view all option was available then.