He was an MVP. Injuries wouldn't allow him to be great long enough.

Whoever thinks Kurt Warner is a bad QB needs brain surgery or something. This guy in my opinion should be in the hall of fame! He has had injury after injury and if it wasn't for bad offensive lines this guy would still be throwing like Manning. He has started in a little more than half the games as Manning (Payton) yet somehow he has been sacked a good 20 more times than him! I'm telling you if Warner was given the same chances as Manning he would still be an elite Quarterback in the NFL!

Might he have gas in the tank? He was better than that punk kid that is suppossed to be the future of the Cardinals. Matt something, I think his name is...

Don't listen to the dumbfuks to voted 3 stars or less. This guy is the most accurate QB in NFL history (yeah, stats show he's 2nd behind Chad Pennington, but if you watch and break down film, you will see it) and was a great QB. Now he's a very good one, still capable of playing well.

Warner is one of the best to play. Everyone talks about the talent that surrounded him at St. Louis. Bulger has duplicated his stats or record. With the Giants he took them from a 1 win team to 5-4 before they put Manning in. They would have went to the playoffs. The Rams receivers used to say that he could put the ball on the left or right should depending where the defender was at. This year He was one game from taking the Cardinals to the playoffs. Martz tried to truin his career and has made it very difficult. There are sure a lot of Rams fans who want him back.

Kurt, I want my beer sacked in paper, and my meats in plastic, thank you. He's a bad quarterback now, nuff said.

listen, I dont care what anybody says kurt warner is a great QB. If it wasnt for the injuruy that occured when he was playing the cowboys, He would have won two more super bowls.

He's more deserving of a backup role than as a starter. The tools he had in St. Louis could have made even Akili Smith look like a hoss. He did terrible what little he played as a Giant. He might do better next year, though, since Arizona has some solid recievers.

Now that Warner is in New York we can see for a fact that Kurt is just an average quarterback with average ools. He looked good in ST. Louis because of the great supporting cast there. In reality, he is your regular number 2 quarterback.

Choked when his team needed him most. Need I say more.

guess he'll be back to bagging my groceries in no time!

overrated, paper mvp. he has shown his true colors. a crybaby p-ssy. marshall faulk should've been mvp the years warner got it. bulger winning there just proves that you can take any sh-tbum from the street and win in that offense. he sucks.

Likeable guy who was an accurate passer 3-4 years ago to a trio of talented receivers. His hand got hurt and he was never the same physically or mentally, again. I doubt anyone will want him as a starting q.b. in the 2004-05 season because he is badly inconsistent and can't seem to stay healthy nor hold onto the ball. Bulger is better than he is, and look for the Rams to get rid of him next season.

Will he bounce back in 2003 or will Bulger take his job? I think Bulger is trade bait after next season. The Greatest Show on Turf will make a comeback, as long as nobody gets hurt, of course. Smiling real big now that he has Pace and Turley protecting him.

the best in the league when healthy and allu stupid f fools that say is overated c kiss m y a*ss ok he is the real deal awsome arm strength best accuracy ive seen he plays in the most potent offense so he wiill bounce back and plus he is that talented

him...bolger...both could do the job..so he does not have that much of an impact.

Kurt Warners would be considered one of the GREATS, that is, if his offensive line could give him more than 2 seconds to get rid of the ball. Too many smacks from behind will tear down any great Quarterback.

To you idiots who are saying Kurt Warner is overrated: overrated compared to who? The fact of the matter is that the guy is one of the best, if not THE best quarterback in football today. His passes are consistently accurate. Sure, he's not absolutely perfect, but what else can you say about someone who came out of nowhere and led his team to the Super Bowl in one year after three losing seasons in a row. It's not just luck or a fluk- Warner is the real deal. I think these folks who say he's overrated are jealous fans of other teams with mediocre QBs. So shut the f--- up! The stats say it all: he consistently throws at least 200 yards and two TDs a game, and is good in the pocket under pressure. Could someone please explain to me why they think those stats are overrated? I'll believe that assertation when the Vikings win the Super Bowl!

He is really an MVP caliber QB. He came back to earth a bit in 2000, but he was injured. He has good timing and touch. Most comparaisons he draws are to Dan Fouts. He makes very quick decisions. Although not a scrambler, Warner is hard to get to because of his quick release. His arm is not as strong as a Peyton Manning or Daunte Culpepper, but the St. Louis system utilizes mostly short to intermediate routes, where Warner's accuracy shines.

i think that we all got to see somthing, that only happens in the movies or in a story. for a guy to get a one in a million chance not only to play in the nfl but to win a superbowl. i think that the nfl better be ready because he has more to show . the rams will win more superbowls as long as warner is the capt. can't wait till this season starts

Way too overrated......he had one good season.....now that every D adjusted to him...they hurt him.....Overrated

When healthy, the best QB.

OVERRATED-OVERRATED-OVERRATED-OVERRATED-OVERRATED.

best QB

Sometimes I think that I could throw for 350 yards and 4 touchdowns in that offense, but that shouldn't diminish what he has done over the last two years. And this year, he has been absolutely unstoppable. He seems to make the correct reads on every play, picking out the right receiver, and hitting him in stride. He is on pace to shatter every single season QB passing record. Short of putting 13 players on defense, I don't know how he can be stopped.

He is the real deal. He throws with supreme confidence to his talented receivers, and is able to move the ball better than any quarterback that I have ever seen. He seems to throw for 300+ yards every game, and the Rams seem to put up 30+ points every game. With the exception of Tampa Bay in last year's NFC championship game, I have yet to see a defense slow him down.

This guy has too much talent around him to be a flash in the pan. But one thing to watch out for is how he handles his newfound celebrity.

This guy is an annoying jesus freak who got lucky.

Second Best QB in football this year.