badgerfan 12/05/2007
He was a five but it seems every part of his game has declined.
Helpful
Funny
Agree
Disagree
HistoryFan 08/09/2006
The best Padre I've ever seen....great guy.
kingguiness 06/07/2005
very good player.
Skizero 03/01/2005
late bloomer who's talent in pittsburgh was matched by his selfishness in the locker room. has that 'juiced' build to him and the downsliding offensive numbers to warrant speculation
OneHungryMonst er 08/23/2004
Largely underrated.
yisman 03/27/2004
He's a 4.5, probably. Definitely a top 10 OF.
PITPIRATES1979 05/27/2003
Sweet B.S.!
wiksik 04/18/2003
decent
the transgressors 04/05/2003
Giles would be terrifying with some protection in the line up!!!
Pantsnat 08/02/2002
The most under-rated player in the world. He's number 2 in OPS. with a 1.063(behind bonds) has 28 homers, 69 RBI's, he's batting .300 and his SLG is .631! I mean come on people, he should at least be in the top 20! And all of this is on a bad team! I bet he'd have like 20 more RBI's if people would get on base infront of him more. This is all in 103 games and 350 AB's
10 reviews! « Previous | Page of 1 | Next »
Sort by Newest Oldest Most helpful Least helpful Highest rated Lowest rated
