RateItAll: The Opinion Network

CSI: Miami has got to be the worst tv show ever. Caruso walks around with slits for eyes, taking his sunglasses ofs and on and off again. The other actors are just as bad. Really horrid show.

This show is my favorite!!!! I am ridiculously obsessed, and Horatio just makes the show! He's my hero! I know it's a little unrealistic, but you've gotta take it with a grain of salt. Why does everyone hate Horatio?

Great except for David "the dork" Caruso.

two words: emily proctor. SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO HOT

Unrealistic and gives people the wrong idea. It should go away.....Soon.

I looooooooove this show!!!!! It is unbelievable and amazing. I mean i know Horatio's (David Caruso) one-liners can be a little out there and down right stupid but still you got to admit...the show is fantastic. it has much more drama and relationship, and everything than the original. David Caruso is sexy in his own way with his scruffy voice, sunglasses, all-black suits, short mysterious relationships (Marisol..never would have worked out anyway), tragic past, (somewhat) innapropriate relationships (Yelina..still gonna happen), random son, and famous one- liners. Right behind him, actually in front of him according to looks is the Hot, sexy, buff, fun, lovable, Eric Delko who has lost his sister, been shot in the head, been sued, and accused of the stupidest things. But as hot as he is and as bad as i feel for him, he will still always have someone there for him, in which i mean I can not get in the way of his obvious love and feelings for Calleigh Duquesne (Emily Proctor) who is a gorgeous southern girl who is totally in love with Eric too and trusts him with her life. Despite her hateable relationship with Jake Berkeley( which might and hopefully be over)...i know she will end up with Eric or else I will kill the show. As impatient as I am Ill be happy to wait as long as I am watching CSI:Miami. But until then I am glad the Ryan is back and in good terms with Alex and Natalia. I am dissappointed though that after the episode "Burned" in the fifth season when Ryan gets fired for his gambling incident, that Yelina Salis, Horatio's sister in-law, shows up after not being there for a few episodes and then leaving and not even being there for the season finale or the 6th season premiere or any of the new Miami episodes. I still have my hopes up that she will return to be on the show...maybe for good..and whenever the series ends (which i hope it never does) or before, that she and Horatio hook up despite she is his brothers ex-wife. But anyway I love Csi:Miami and all the suspense, drama, relationships and anticipation that goes on. This show is definitely one to get hooked and addicted on and to fall in love with. I get obesessed really easily anyway but.. its definietly on my top three..tied with the unforgettable Friends. So my rating is a 10, two thumbs up, and must see!!!

Okay, so we all have to admit that Caruso can't act. He says corny 1-liners, repeats back everything every other characters says before responding, and can't saying a single line without tilting his head and twitching his eyes. But I have to say wrinkles and all, he's still sexy (and I'm 23) and Delko and Wolfe definitely are hot too. Plus, I think the show, especially lately, is starting to get a bit steamier. Overall, I rate this show ADDICTIVE.

What's next--CSI Antarctica? How about CSI Sierre Leone.

Caruso annoys me. This show is far from reality.

David Caruso must have graduated from the William Shatner school for over acting. How many times can he put on and take off his shades for dramatic effect per episode? Was much better as Mitch the cop in First Blood.

I wasn't a big TV watcher until the CSI's came out. I love them all, especially this one because of the acting of all players and David Caruso.

I LOVE this show!! A new guilty pleasure! As a video production teacher, the editing is awesome, making even classically boring lab scenes interesting. David Caruso IS Horation Caine, and he IS the show! Without him, I would stop watching. Emily Proctor is disarming with her sweet voice contrasting her dead serious agenda. Duh, of course, David is posturing and he does it better than anyone on television. Just like Tom Cruise in Top Gun. It's a fun thing to watch. If you are going to posture, then posture well. That's the whole point.

All the CSI series are great but Miami edges it for me. Maybe the setting's got something to do with it. David Caruso's very charismatic in his role. What's particularly good about the CSI series is the science behind the forensics. Now I'm not a forensic scientist so I'm not sure how accurate the 'science' is here but it at least it is logical and convincing.

I know it's unfair to base my rating on just one episode - I watched the season premier a couple weeks ago. But this evidently is one of those shows you couldn't understand unless you watch from the very beginning. Anyway the show seemed very boring and "artificial". The graphics looks horrible - they have an obsession with orange and green in this show.

i love this show! it glamorizes miami... & trust me....miami is not all that! but i am a david caruso fan...(dunt know y!) i stopped watching nypd becuz he left!

Glad to know I'm not the only one who finds David Caruso an irritating and awful actor. He just stinks up the screen with his posturing and postulating. At first, I thought he was going for camp, it was so bad. Actually, that's how I can tolerate watching him now -- I just laugh at his overacting ass.

This is the absolute WORST of the CSI series. The acting is that of a high school drama club. The plots are horrible and filled with useless one-liners. I just saw the latest episode involving a bunch of gamers who get bored with violent games and move into the real thing. Talk about trying to use shock value for ratings. In conclusion, acting: horrible - plot: horrible - stupidity: incredible. This series makes me enjoy the original CSI and CSI: New York even more than before (it's one of those better by comparison things). I'll celebrate when this series finally gets canned from low ratings.

As they say: He poses for 10 minutes and acts for 1! Get rid of the lead and improve the program!

I think i'm going to have to clear something up here. The creators of CSI: MIAMI wanted to make the spin-off (I have never liked that label but ill use it anyway) as different from Vegas as possible. This show has a more cop feel to it. They pull out their guns every episode. Horatio Cares, and i mean really cares, about the victims and their families, Calliegh comes in with her kit and cute southern accent and KICK'S ASS, Delko dives for tresure, Alexx talks to dead people (And she is so much better than that kid in The Sixth Sense) and Yelina battles her attraction to Horatio and her Loyalty to his Not-quite-so-dead brother, her ex-husband. And they do all this in the most beautiful, sunny setting imaginable. These Characters are believeable, and the actors that play them are brilliant in making them so believeable. David Caruso is a great actor. His ability to make you cry is fantastic and real. Horatio is dedicated to his job, to catching the bad guy, Grissom is dedicated to the science of crime scene investigating. Furthermore, scince the writers decided to split up the Vegas team there has been a distict lack of unity in the show. One of the reasons i love these shows is because the characters really interact with each other, all the time. MIAMI is still a unified team, im hoping vegas will get that aspect back. All three CSI shows have differences and they are all good. Stop comparing each show to one another and start appreciating them as great shows on their own.

I love CSI Miami and David Caruso. He is perfect as Horatio! It wouldn't be a show without him!