Bad Money: Reckless Finance, Failed Politics, and the Global Crisis of American Capitalism (Kevin Phillips)
2
Keven Phillips is a very intelligent man. He is extremely well read. Somewhere along the way, however, he has decided that nothing can save America from its own terminal idiocy.
Here is his argument in a nutshell. America is doomed. We are a declining empire, whose rapid descent into powerlessness and shame is probably unstoppable, in any event, but which is utterly inevitable given the idiocy and buffoonery of our leaders. What dooms us, says Phillips, is a combination of an economy increasingly devoted to parasitic financial speculators, instead of companies which make real products, vast levels of debt, both private and public, the imminent double-whammy of oil running out and global warming, the domination of the Republican Party by know-nothing evangelicals and the absolute and total horror of the Bush Administration.
It is customary, in books of this sort, after demonstrating the evils of whatever the author is denouncing, to then move on, in the last chapter, to at least a brief description of how we could fix everything, if we would simply listen to the author's wisdom. Phillips will have none of that. We are DOOMED, doomed, don't you understand, and he does not bother trying to discuss how the descent into hell could be slowed.
There are, of course, many aspects of his analysis that are well-grounded factually. The excesses of our financial system, at this point, are obvious to everyone. The issues that he raises about oil shortages are certainly quite real and worth serious thought. On many points of detail, Phillips has and presents an excellent understanding of current political and economic events.
The overall tone of the book, however, is absurd. We must fail, because all empires before us, the Roman, the Spanish, the Dutch and the British, all failed. What a load of pompous nonsense! The Roman, the Spanish, the Dutch and the British Empires have almost nothing in common with each other, never mind with America. Phillips' whole effort to state a grand theory of history is simply a provincial re-hash of the old "decline of the West" thinking. American power might well fail, but, if so, it won't be for the same reasons that the Romans, the Spanish, the Dutch and the British failed; there is no common thread running through all of these stories, except perhaps the universal truth that all human creations fall apart sooner or later.
Phillips has no appreciation of America's ability at self-correction. Yes, the housing bubble, following on the internet bubble and prior bubbles, was a disaster of epic proportions, for which Alan Greenspan and George W. Bush have much to answer. But the system has already liquidated every single sub-prime lender and most of the bulls on Wall Street. We are past that piece of insanity, and it seems quite unlikely that we will be going down that road again any time soon. Could the Roman, Spanish, Dutch or British Empires change course this quickly? One little difference between us and them.
And, if Bush was elected, because the know-nothing bozos in the South, who are dumb enough to still take the Bible seriously control our elections, how was it that Barack Obama won in 2008? Obama, in many ways, is the polar opposite of George W. Bush. Our system elected him after Bush. Does that sound like a doomed, dying empire, unable to change course or to correct mistaken policies?
And, of course, Phillips takes it for granted that the whole world hates us for the abysmal failure of Bush's criminal policy of invading Iraq to grab its oil. Phillips, of course, is far too sophisticated to be taken in by that liar Bush's empty pretense that the war in Iraq might have something to do with democracy and ridding the world of tyrants. As I write this, Iraq is concluding its provincial elections, in which every major group in Iraq participated and which were carried out peacefully. And in which the religious extremists parties appear to have lost, big time. Something tells me that George W. Bush's bad public opinion ratings in Norway in 2004 will not matter much, to future historians, if Bush has in fact succeeded at creating a lasting democracy in the center of the Arab Middle East. And it is kind of hard to see America as a doomed, hopelessly declining power, when we achieve feats such as these.
Beneath Phillips' intelligence and erudition, this book stinks. If you want an explanation of the current crisis, there are many better ones out there. But Phillips' real concern is not the current crisis. His real perspective is the latest in a line of gloom and doom prophets reaching back to Paul Ehrlich, and the various authors who told us that Japan was going to take over the world. Jews are familiar with the odd phenomena of the "self-loathing Jew." Phillips is an example of that odd sub-species, the highly educated and extremely successful American who prides himself on his ability to see how shallow, ugly and tacky America is and who takes tremendous pleasure in predicting American decline. Sorry, Mr. Phillips, but betting against America has always been a bad bet. We have come through worse things than this, and something tells we will come through this one, too.