A lovely gift for all involved.

Gifts for women? Who are we kidding? This gift is for MEN! Women just happen to be wearing it!

As my sister so eloquently put it, "Some lingere makes a woman feel sexy, some makes her feel like meat."  Choose wisely or choose something else.

The gift that keeps on giving!!!

So the debate here is whether it's really a gift for the man or for the woman. While I appreciate the gesture of going with her to pick it out, that would really hurt the prized "first impression" I love when getting to view how gorgeous my girlfriend looks in something revealing & sensual. Here is the other side of the coin: My girl doesn't wear good lingerie nearly enough! This is a major problem for me, and there has been plenty of communication. What to do? Ladies, while I understand that this may not be the perfect gift, take a moment to realize that we wouldn't NEED to use a gift-giving occasion if it were sufficiently present in our lives to begin with...

I would rather go with them to pick it out instead. That way we can both decide what is in our taste.

I always figure that when I give my wife this, I'm really giving myself a present.

Eh. It's my experience that guys don't really care much for the wrapping so much as the present ; ). UPDATE: Caution: if you get your women the wrong size (esp. if it's larger), you may have hell to pay! Might want to steer clear of this unless you're SURE of what size she wears!

I really like giving this gift to my wife. But in all fairness, it's really more of a gift for me than for her. If we're going to be unselfish, we need to give them something THEY want.

I give that 5 Stars with a catch: the other gifts can't be something like a bread maker, an oven mit, or even a set of cookware. I'm thinking more like jewelry or something she says she really, really want. And don't buy her a g-string or a thong if she hates wearing them. Just because she looks good in it doesn't mean it's a good gift. After all, us guys hope that this is one present that hopefully ends up thrown across the bedroom at the end of the night.

More a gift for the man than for the woman. Let your woman surprise you with lingerie (you can always tell her what you like). Get her gifts she can use outside the house for the holidays.

Certainly not all, but I think at least some women enjoy receiving and wearing pretty, silky lacy things. I especially enjoy lingerie that has a kind of late 19th century feeling. A little romance in your life never hurts!

I think it's okay for some people. I for one don't have a problem with it. I think it's a compliment if a guy buys his woman lingerie because apparently if he didn't think you looked good in it he wouldn't buy it. Sexy things should boost our confidence, especially if our men make us feel good about ourselves.

I can't think of one woman that would appreciate getting lingerie as a gift. Besides if you don't know what type or size she likes you'd better go dig yourself a grave. Lingerie is definently not a good gift!

I think this item is on the wrong list. I mean isn't lingerie a holiday gift for men? Give me a break! I'm not objecting to people buying and wearing lingerie, but I don't think lingerie is an appropriate holiday gift for a woman. Really good gifts focus on the recipient, and lingerie clearly does not fall into that category. Two thumbs way down!