Road Pinella's coattails in 2003, and showed his true skill in 2004. Enjoy him Diamondbacks.

fire him!

I guess 1 is the lowest you can rate. Send him out of Seattle and what the hell were they thinking when Bill Bavasi was named GM. Send his ass home as well. By the way the Angels didn't win the World Series until he left them.

They may be an old team, but they still should have won somewhere in the neighborhood of 70-80 games. Fire Melvin!

He's asleep. He's a wimp. He's a loser. Other than that, I say just fire him.

Bob Melvin was dealt a tough situation with the acquisition of veteran players to an already veteran team. He has made some solid managerial decisions this year and with the addition of new talent, next year should be on par with the excellence Mariners fans have come to expect.

Bob Melvin should not be the skipper for the mariners next year. He is totally clueless. Get rid of him. It would serve the management right if ticket sales dramatically dropped soon. I know I haven't gone as much. Get a clue!

I like his style managering i hope more from him this year.

Rookie manager got them in a pennant race!