 | Moosekarloff (19)
01/26/2006 | Tremendous film, well worth its reputation. Great script, great performances, intelligent, serious film. Wouldn't make much of an impression of most of the clods in America during this post-literate era we're living in, basically because it wouldn't be likely that a video game tie-in could be established. Also, no special effects. And Reese Witherspoon, Tom Cruise, Ben-Wa Affleck and none of the other two dozen or so no-talents on the Hollywood round robin are in the cast.
(5 voted this helpful, 0 funny and 0 agree) |
 | john davies (2)
02/26/2002 | Long regarded as one of the outright masterpieces of world cinema,Renoir's 1937 anti-war film was the first in a "foreign language" to be nominated for the Best Film Oscar.Its tale of French soldiers in a World War 1 German prisoner of war camp was banned by Goebbels not for any anti-German feeling but precisely for the depth of its wisdom and its message of common shared humanity across national boundaries.Typically,Renoir conveys his message cinematically,without resorting to preaching or over-emphasis,the dialogue is intelligent as ever,the performances by a notable cast(including the great Jean Gabin,and the former famous director Erich Von Stroheim,whom many will remember as the butler in Sunset Boulevard)superb,and the plot itself never less than fully involving.Still a tremendous,inspirational and totally relevant film experience.
(3 voted this helpful, 0 funny and 0 agree) |
