Super Bowl III (1969, N.Y. Jets 16, Baltimore 7)
5
Biggest upset in sports history? Maybe not, but definitely the biggest in Super Bowl History. The Baltimore Colts were 18 1/2 point favorites going into Miami to face The Jets in Super Bowl III. This game, perhaps wasn't so much won by The Jets, as it was lost by The Colts who made mistake after mistake.
On The Colts first possession they drove steadily down the field all the way to The Jets 19 yard line. They had to settle for a FG attempt but K, Lou Michels missed from 27 yards out. At the very end of the 1st quarter The Colts got a huge break when CB Lenny Lyles knocked the ball from Jets WR, George Sauer and recovered it on The Jets 12. However on 3rd and 4 from The Jets 6, Morrall's pass for Tom Mitchell bounced off his shoulder pads and was intercepted by Randy Beverly. The Colts were turned back yet again. This was perhaps, the turning point in the game as The Jets used this interception as the springboard for an impressive 80 yard TD drive. Jets RB, Matt Snell carried the ball 6 times on the drive for a total of 35 yards and culminated the 80 yard march with a 4 yard TD run over the left side of the line.
The Colts again drove to The Jets 38 yard line, the big play in the drive was a 30 yard pass from QB Earl Morrall to RB Tom Matte but again, K Lou Michaels missed the FG. After Jets K, Jim Turner missed a FG The Colts took over on their 20 yard line and drove 65 yards to The Jets 15 yard line. The big play in this drive was a 58 yard run by RB Tom Matte (the 58 yard run was the longest in Super Bowl history until Raiders RB, Marcus Allen went 74 yards for a TD against The Redskins in Super Bowl XVIII). But once again The Colts were turned back when Earl Morrall, badly, underthrew the intended receiver, Willie Richardson and the pass was intercepted by The Jets, Johnny Sample.
The Colts would get yet, another shot in the 1st half when they forced The Jets to punt from their own 7 yard line and received the ball in great field position at The Jets 42 yard line. On 2nd an 9 The Colts used a play that they'd used successfully earlier in the season. Morrall handed the ball to Tom Matte, who lateraled back to Morrall, who then, again, badly underthrew a pass intended for FB Jerry Hill and the pass was intercepted at The Jets 21 yard line by Jim Hudson. The real tragedy of the play was that, the primary receiver in the pattern, Jimmy Orr was standing all alone near the goal line but Morrall threw the pass down the middle of the field where Hudson intercepted. The 1st half ended with The Jets up 7-0 and The Colts left wondering what might have been
The Jets dominated the 2nd half of the game and it all started when Colts RB, Tom Matte fumbled on the 1st play of the 2nd half. The Jets recovered and Jim Turner kicked his 1st of 3 FG's to give The Jets a 10-0 lead. The Jets would go on to win the game 16-7.
This game put Jets QB Joe Namath (who guaranteed a victory) on the map. Joe Namath owes his whole career to this game and although he had a nice day completing 17-28 for 206 yards and was named MVP of the game, I can't help but wonder why Jets RB Matt Snell wasn't chosen for the award. It was the running ability of Snell who allowed The Jets to control the ball and time of possession, especially in the 2nd half. Snell carried the ball 30 times for 121 yards and The Jets only TD.
This game put The AFL on the map and there would be only one more season before the 2 leagues would merge in 1970.