RateItAll: The Opinion Network

clay and ruben were so talented. they both won my heart. this was the season that got me hooked.

This is when this show got cheesy. Ooh if I wear a chicken suit or a weird dress I will be on t.v. wow! This is also the season when Simon and Paula started having their fake t.v. arguments.

I strongly do not want to see Gay Aiken and Ruben Butthead everywhere on anything entertainment-related. Their music should be banned from the airwaves. The people who watched this show are plain stupid. All you people think Simon is funny, should get a life. He and Randy should all be banned from television. End this series now!

It's the season that got me watching the show. I thought anyone from the top three deserved to win. My only real problem then is the same problem I have now: I don't like the voting system. They should allow one vote per person so it's more about the talent than about speed dial.

Great show, but clay should've won...

loved it . both ruben and clay are adorable and lovable and talented

why would you want to watch glorified karyoke. I would much rather eat my vomit.

Much better than season 1. They had 5 great singers and all of them made it to the final 5. I was very happy about that. Ruben is the American Idol but I was rooting for Clay Aiken.

best season eva !

If I didn't like American Idol 1 how on earth could I like American Idol 2.

Inoffensive, but again, reality shows aren't my thing.

The show it's self is Awsome. However Clay should have one.

Clay should have won! Recount the hanging chads!

too bad we cant rate a big fat ZERO on this show, waste of time in primetime !

stupid show just goes to show you that rupert murdock has his hands on the pulse of amerikkans.

love the show!

I love All of the American Idol seasons

This is the first american Idol I had watched straight through. The first american Idol I only saw parts of, but this was however by far the better of the first and the third. Clay Aiken should have won but it was the people all around the usa who wanted to voiced their opion and that is quite a phenonemon thing. I thing it is the best way and the most easiet way to help get your singing career to a great fantastic start.

I would have said great but the final vote was fixed which bummed me out

OK. I have to tell the truth, Carmen Rasmusen was my favorite American Idol. But now that i go back a listen to her, she is not all that great. She should probbally just stick with yodeling. But my present favorite would have to be Trenyce. She out beats everyone by far! I mean look at her song that she performed by Whitney Houston I Have Nothing she sounded just like her. But back to the others. Venessa Olivarez- She should have gotten at least forth maybe fifth, But no what America saw in her was another Nikki McKibben or Kelly Osbourne. She is way better than those two wannabe's. Charles Grigsby- What else can i say? He cant sing! No Talent. He is like last years E.J. Day or whatever his name is. Julia Dematto- Shes alright she shuld have gotten, maybe 7th, not really any talent there. Corey Clark- SO dum with no talent.Rickey Smith- Herculees Hurculees! ahh i love it. Kimberly Caldwell- Get over the camera we are interested in other American Idols. Not you!(typical cheerleader) Carmen Rasmusen- What happened? You shuld have gotten fifth at least. I love you. Trenyce- What the crap? You are my American Idol, You should have won. Shoo Ruben. Josh Gracin- You were just the ladies eye candy you cant sing! Kim. Locke- Now you can sing keep rollin. CLay Aiken. Your alright. i Hate ur face motions. Roben Studdard -you should not have won, we all no why you won. your nothing special at stardom. SO basically there is my take on the AI2 show. Aand actually i believe FRENCHIE should have won. THEY were jsut scarred pof her talent. THey also no that if she was in the show, she would have won and there would have been no competion. BUt yea bye