Of course it was unrealistic and silly-it's a FANTASY.The acting,casting,sets,costumes and special effects were marvelous.The only problem I had with it was that it was WAY too long.A movie that you can watch with children and both be entertained.

I rate Johnny Depp's performance 5 stars, but the movie overall just 2 stars for being such a silly, unrealistic thing...

I just watched this last night. Not for the first time of course. I've watched it so many times, I basically have it memorized. I love this movie. I think it was so well done. They couldn't have picked better actors to play the characters. It was brilliant.

the death of Johnny Depp as a respectable actor.

An extremly fun film. Everthing from the spetacular special effects to the hilarious performance from Johny Depp this movie is a fun filled adventure that does everything right. Can't wait for the sequel.