I'm not really sure why everyone raves about this mascara. I personally think its average. It was one of the first mascara's I used as a teen and even then I thought it was only ok! My lashes didn't look bad, but they didn't look great! I also really hate the brush!

Read the label...among other nasties, the fourth ingredients (the first being water), is SHELLAC... do you really want to intentionally put shellac on or near your eyes? I do not and will not. I wish more women were aware of this.

One of the worst mascaras I ever tried. Wimpy, clumpy overall junk. Cant understand why everyone loves this! I'll stick to my old favorites

I have tried everything... they were so thick and clumpy and i never liked that. But this is the best that i ever tried and it is really cheap too. it washes out when i go swimming but besides that it is GREAT..

It can be a little messy, so it takes a seasoned mascara lover to apply... but... It lengthens, it thickens, it layers well, it holds a curl after curling, it lasts all day, it doesn't flake. Don't get me started on how much i LOVE the new "blackest black" color. I love the pink tube. The original, and still the best. There's a reason why supermodels still swear by it. Oh, and it's cheap.