yucko

I'm not sure if this is the same as the Colorstay Overtime Lash Tint but if it is I have to say so far so good. I like the idea of a mascara lasting for a couple of days and even though there were a couple of specs under my eyes after sleeping I easily removed this with a little vaseline and vitamin E. Every mascara I have ever tried (and at 39 I've tried a lot) has left me with raccoon eyes in just a couple of hours. My recommendation is to wipe the brush first before applying. Of course; it is winter and dry out. I think the real test is summer - mega humidity here in the north.

This product is really weird. I tried it because REAL SIMPLE magazine gave it rave reviews, but maybe I just didn't use it right or got a bad tube, because I found it really really really really LIQUIDY and hard to apply. It did stay on, but the liquidness of the stuff just sort of put me off. Plus, who wants to wear mascara for 3 days (especially if I have to take off the rest of my eye makeup anyway!)

This mascara made my lashes flake and I had two black eyes by day's end. It was difficult removing the product, too. Even though I used my BeautiControl mascara remover (oily), I couldn't remove all of the smudges.