Looking more and more like a 1 year wonder. A bad decision by the Giants, to throw a long term contrac at him  for all that money - but then again, perhaps they - temporarily- felt that having players who began their careers in Troy playing against a Babylonian team in which Hammurabi was the cleanup hitter wasn't working out so well.

Was a five, but too early in career to give him five star for life.

Update: This guy stinks. How did he ever win? He gets torched every time hes on the mound.

He benefitted from playing in Oakland, one of the best pitchers parks in baseball, which made him look better than he is. Moving to pitcher unfriendly Pac-Bell has exposed his weaknesses. I'm not saying he's a bad pitcher, I'm just saying that like a lot of pitchers who have come out of Oakland, the stadium helped him a lot.

A quality pitcher who is in a slump on a struggling team. The Phillies will gladly send the As Polanco, Padilla, and Liberthal for Zito and Kendall. Any takers?

Good pitcher, but he's been slumping.

Struggling a lot this year. Still a decent starter, but I'm not sure if he will be able to be dominant like he was in previous years.

Patrick Duffy's nephew.

Unreal curveball, best I've ever seen. Still young, already won Cy Young Award. Having a mediocre year, but still pitching great.

best pitcher in baseball!!!

He is better than Pedro now. Has great control of his pitches, and he pitches with great confidence.