I have studied in both McGill University and Université Laval. I can say McGill staff are rude and lazy. The registration office easily ignore your emails. It was unbelievable for me. I never had a bad minute in Université Laval.

McGill is a great school with an even greater reputation. You will find McGill alumni all over the world. I work for a bulge bracket firm on Wall Street and on some days I run into so many McGill people that I feel like I'm back in Montreal!

If you're in Arts in McGill I feel bad for you. Everything else is world class (faculty-wise at least). Oh yeah and the bureacracy sucks, sometimes hard to be an undergrad in some of the bigger departments. Still has a great reputation and I can see why!

I am a recent McGill Medical School graduate. McGills curriculum prepared me well to excel at many clinical settings including Harvards Massachusetts General Hospital where I am doing my residency. From administration, through housing to teaching, McGill was superb. Anyone saying otherwise needs to do some serious introspection.

Dont listen to Queen's person's comment. McGill is one of the most respected school in the world. Easily ranked as top 100 Universities in numerous rankings. 100 times better than Queen's University.

This school has been nothing but a dissapointment. From housing to teaching this school is a disgrace. Admin staff is lazy and incompentent. You can never find a place to study. The building are falling apart and nobody cares. There are way better schools in Canada than this. Trust me don't go to this school.

As a 3d year McGill Student I can say that the place is just horrible. Although there are a few smaller departments where you as a student will deal mainly with good, caring faculty and can avoid the B.S. and the bureaucracy, on the whole, McGill is a despicable sh*thole. Besides the crumbling facilities, the library that loses books returned by students and then charges the costs to them even when they find them later and the large portion of the faculty that would rather have a university without students, the Administration and staff could be accurately described as the worst of any major Canadian University. These people are lazy, incompetent, contemptuous of students, and only show up for work about five hours a day, 3 and half days a week. And good luck trying to get one of them on the phone or to solve problems that they themselves had caused.


If Heather Munroe Blum ever were to get her big tuition hike, I would be willing to bet that the increase in funding will go to maybe a few small research grants in medicine in the science, with the rest being fed to the bureaucracy to make things even worse than they are. If I could do it again, I would go to Concordia. As it stands, I don't even plan to go to my own graduation ceremony, because when the Chancellor hands me my diploma, I'm sure I'd tell him something, but it sure as hell wouldn't be "thank you".

Terrible administration, poor teaching, might be good for future corporate b****** or stupid blond girls studying political science because they have nothing better to do. No 1 university for bench drinkers and Paris Hilton look-a-likes. GET ME OUT OF HERE!!!!

Its undoubtedly one of the best schools not only in Canada but in the world. I am a student of this University and in my 3rd year and I will again apply to this school for my Grad Studies.

McGill Graduate Housing is horrible!! I have had a very bad time at this university. I am glad I am done and getting out of this miserable school. The buidling are literally falling apart, most people in the city are cold and very unfriendly - so are the professors. The only positive thing about going to McGill is the partying and drinking cause Montreal has good bars.

It's my 4th and final year at McGill and I have to say that this university is amazing. It's true its not easy to get funding or scholarships and the administration is slow but so many other things make it great. The student body is diverse, international, and overall brilliant. You can make excellent contacts and will be challenged by other students you meet. The professors here are TOP quality and DO care about their students. It is extremely competitive and you are forced to learn some French if you want to fully integrate into Montreal society. This to me, is a positive and it builds your character. Also, no small-town boredom here--there is always something to do. At the same time, everything is readily accessible not like in Toronto, let's say. And for the record, the international reputation is extremely helpful when applying for jobs & internships...

Not a very good school for a variety of reasons. Yes the tuition is cheap but only if you're from Quebec and you get what you pay for. There are plenty of better schools in Ontario. The main problem at this school is lack of study space. Also McGill graduate housing is really horrible. See http://3464hutchison.tripod.com for pics from (I think) the student soceity.

Not a very good school for a variety of reasons. Yes the tuition is cheap but only if you're from Quebec and you get what you pay for. There are plenty of better schools in Ontario.

Simply a superb school, and is known to be the top Canadian university and as Harvard of the North.

I had many troubles with this school as well. Not a very pleasant environment. McGill Graduate Housing also provides terrible housing for its students.

I have to say I agree. McGill is definitely one of the most underfound universities of Canada. I didn't know that till I chose to come here and found out that all master students in my group has no funding at all. Even some Ph.D have to support themselves..Compare to UBC (where I could stay), McGill is definitely poor..At UBC the tuition for international is $7200/year and schoool pays half of that automatically, but at McGill tuition is about $10000/year and you pay all! Administration at McGill sucks too..also, ppl here don't really care about students. I had this great opportunity to work with Nortel for my 16 months internship. But department terms me down by not supporting me for a work permit..The reason was that there's no such program for graduate student..

hey! right...i've given mcgill 3 stars b'coz i dont actually go 2 the uni itself! so basically, from hearing all the comments im still deciding! im a student @ the university of hertfordshire in england (20mins 4rm london) and am looking for a uni 2 do my exchange in in my 3rd yr (currently in 1st). mcgill is 1 of the unis on da list! so helo me out guys. b really honest! it depends of u guys if i go or not :P

This school is relatively poor in many areas. The administration is a nightmare. They always pass the buck and never get anything done. The school is seriously underfunded and provides nothing to graduates students. Your just a number and in most cases treated relatively poor. Montreal is okay if you like bars and restruants but the city is very run down and underdelevopled. There are absolutely no jobs here unless you are bi-lingual. Graduate housing is extremely bad (see 3464 rue hutchison pictures for an example: http://3464hutchison.tripod.com I have no idea whatsoever why McGill has such a good reputation. Schools like Queens Toronto Western Laurier UBC Waterloo are far better both in terms of research and facilties for thier students. There is no reason to choose this school. Maybe for Medical school its okay but otherwise seriously do NOT go to this school especially for graduate studies.

This school is relatively poor in many areas. The administration is a nightmare. They always pass the buck and never get anything done. The school is seriously underfunded and provides nothing to graduates students. Your just a number and in most cases treated relatively poor. Montreal is okay if you like bars and restruants but the city is very run down and underdelevopled. There are absolutely no jobs here unless you are bi-lingual. Graduate housing is extremely bad (see 3464 rue hutchison pictures for an example: http://3464hutchison.tripod.com I have no idea whatsoever why McGill has such a good reputation. Schools like Queens Toronto Western Laurier UBC Waterloo are far better both in terms of research and facilties for thier students. There is no reason to choose this school. Maybe for Medical school its okay but otherwise seriously do NOT go to this school especially for graduate studies.

ITS SIMPLY A GREAT SCHOOL!!!!

McGill is the most capitalist university I went to, it does not care at all about the students. All student services are privatized (the bookstore is owned by Chapters). Probably the worst administration and campus organization you can get. Way over rated.

By far Canada's top unveristy, need I say more? Diveristy of the student, top professers, wide-range of courses, beautiful campus and amazing location. McGill has it all, obvious it has a few flaws because nothing is perfect but that's life. It may take longer to get an advising appointment and students may be encouraged to do things on their own but it prepares you for the real world. McGill is competitive but so is the marketplace. McGill is an institution of higher learning, it's survival of the fittest at McGill, if you don't make the cut then you don't dererve to graduate with a McGill degree.

Definitely the best school in Canada, also among the top 10 (overall) North America institutions. Very tough and changelling courses, exciting compus environment, top professors,... No matter what degree you have achieved from McGill, it will be the proud of your life time.

McGill is probably the best option for those thinking of an MBA: - Best ROI - Superb mix of international and experienced peers and teachers. - You'll get prestidge: they call it the Harvard of Canada, it is the best known Canadian option. -Location, location location: magnificent Montreal! Just a few hours form Toronto or New York if you ever need a gib anglophone city. -The most international program in the NAFTA region.

School cares more about it's image then their students.

But it's so damn cold, aye Canucks??

Great School

Well, technically I am not enrolled in the business school ie. the MBA program. However, I am a BCOM student (that is McGill's term for an undergraduate management student). While the core management courses are at sometimes questionable, McGill's reputation, faculty, and diversity make it an excellent choice. As an undergraduate student you are given the ability to take management courses in conjunction with those in the arts and sciences. This allows one to gain a greater perspective, and provides a relief from the monotany of the management core. Montreal, is also an undeniable benefit of studying at McGill, it provides numerous cultural diversions and an atmosphere conducive to studying business. I have enjoyed both the classes and the diverse student body. I highly recommend this school!

I'd agree with Groo. But I've definetly had fun so far in Montreal. In Montreal you can learn French, if you are so inclined, which is a bonus. But the school itself has been a disappointment. Student bodies are internationl everywhere now, as our successful alumni when you are talking about the world's best b-schools. I'm not sure why that translates into 5 stars. If you could place an Ivey or Sobey school of business in Montreal you would definetly have the perfect school! Until then you have to make your choice!

As a McGill student I can offer some insight. McGill enjoys a good reputation in Canada, I don't think that this is directly rated to the business school though. Canada's graduate business powers are Western, Saint Mary's & perhaps Schulich (York). One of the benefits of McGill is its location in Montreal -no need to tolerate London, Ontario. Another advantage is really cheap tuition but you get what you pay for. If I could go back in time I would definetly have looked very seriously at Saint Mary's University in Halifax. It might be North America's best bang for your buck.

Despite the fact that McGill is relatively undefunded in comparison to its US counterparts, the school has maintained an impressive faculty and rolled out a slew of successfull alumni. The mere internationalism of both the student body and faculty are reason enough to attend giving those MBA grads an edge in the global economy.

According to what I've read and researched, McGill is the Wharton of Canada

international reputation is not enough to be among the elite b-schools.