Still the man.  I like him better than Tom Brady.

Brady and him are the current best.

Runs a great offense, a great team leader. Very motivated but also able to relax and stay calm. Great arm, great decision maker and his small steps make him agile in the pocket. Throws very well on the run, has excellent communication with his wide receivers and line. Deadly accurate. His average speed and lack of natural manouvres aren't a factor, as he has good vision and awareness of his blockers. Great timing, great quarterback. If the defense had gotten there act together as well as New England nobody would be questioning how well he does in the playoffs.

has been the best in the nfl for years and now has that ring to silence all doubters

You can't find any other QB in NFL history that has complete control over his offensive line. And at times has even told the head coach to take the Defence off the field cause he's going for it. Though he gets on some peoples nerves I think it mostly stims from the fact that they do not have playing for their select team.

payton just cant win in stressful positions the main reason i think is because dungey give's him to much to process at the line. he's triyng to out think a definsive coordinator plus three guys in a nice comfy booth none of wich have anyone trying to kill them.i think this is why he can win in the regular season but by playoff time the defenses have seen him and can ajust and come with a game plan whereas he's trying to figure on as he goes and he just cant out think a playoff caliber defensive crew.bottom line tony has to take some of the control from him and place it where it belongs with the coordinator

Yes, until he plays in the playoffs. I've always thought that Vanderjagt was right about him.

untill he wins that title he cant get a 5 from me

MANNING IS GOOD NOT ELI BUT THE PEYTON. HE IS A HELL OF A QUATERBACK, BUT I STILL WILL HAVE BREES, BRADY, OR MCNABB RUNNIG MY OFFENSE RATHER THAN PEYTON

He's a hell of a talent, but so far you have to question his inability to perform in the clutch.