he is better lookin' then all them busted n**ga especially that damn LeBron James

Taken a step back from his super rookie year. Probably #4 now on the James-Wade-Bosh 03 draft ladder.

I think carmelo Anthony is the goodest player out there since I see he is the one who brought his team the Denver Nuggets to the playoff.

he was the best rookie he should've won ROY he actually got his team on the playoffs not like that other guy what's his name.

Wah wah. This guy whines like a baby. The baby blue colors of Denver fit him perfectly.

yo this kid ballin straight out of control like taylor jannsen

after making NUGGETS to playoffs since 1994-1995 seasons, he's definitely the SOLO ROOKIE OF THE YEAR. CARMELO-NUGGETS-WEST-PLAYOFFS vs LEBRON-CAVS-EAST-GONE FISHING...... what an obvious choice

MUCH BETTER THEN THAT PHENOM,WHATS HIS NAME? LEBR WHAT?

LeBron is an outstanding player; Carmelo is an awesome player. Which one is better? Melo all the way is what I say. He may be young, but he's not as young as LeBron. LeBron plays like he's young; he's gettin out of that hole, but he's still got a year or two before he'll completely shine. I say Carmelo for Rookie of the Year, no doubt about it. Carmelo's got the charisma and skill to be the next MJ or Magic.

Good player but nowhere near as good as Lebron. Shoots an awful percentage and shoots too much. Will win a few rings.

yea

to me carmelo is the best rookie in the league and he should've been the first player to be drafted.

sugar, and spice. He's good!