hunt1120 02/29/2008
I have loved Charly from the moment I met her in 3rd grade.
Helpful
Funny
Agree
Disagree
Maomania 02/27/2005
She is not that good. She was good enough for the semi final, but that's it. Not material for the final 12.
latoyalondon#1 05/17/2004
she's not that good---and her chain of fools was off pitch the entire duration of the song--if she can sing that well, why did she sound that bad??? she's not what i'd call a talented singer--mediocre at best
TSGGB 04/27/2004
She should have been a Top 12 finalist... please, give her John Stevens spot... I dug her.
sikao 04/25/2004
Charly was the first American Idol contestant to motivate me to get off of my couch and actually vote! I hope gets a record deal, because I'd buy her album and go to concert in a heartbeat.
i_am_a_legend 04/13/2004
i'm giving him a 1 coz i cant give her a 0
CherrySoda99 04/07/2004
Charly was ok. She had a nice voice, but not American Idol material. Actually, I think almost everybody that was in the Final 32, could've had a good chance in the top 12, I mean, look at some of the ones that are there now.
Jazza 04/05/2004
yer it was orrite not my cup of tea but you know it wasnt bad she had a good voice but not quite good enough
Sword_Metalize d 04/03/2004
She has a great voice and she is a an absolute doll, would of liked to see her in the Top 12... She is the cutest, prettiest contestant, & I love to hear to her talk, what a sweety.. If anyone know her tell her that I would love a date!!! ;~)
Nightmaiden 03/24/2004
I thought she was going to do well untill her last performance :(
10 reviews! « Previous | Page of 1 | Next »
Sort by Newest Oldest Most helpful Least helpful Highest rated Lowest rated