I have loved Charly from the moment I met her in 3rd grade.

She is not that good. She was good enough for the semi final, but that's it. Not material for the final 12.

she's not that good---and her chain of fools was off pitch the entire duration of the song--if she can sing that well, why did she sound that bad??? she's not what i'd call a talented singer--mediocre at best

She should have been a Top 12 finalist... please, give her John Stevens spot... I dug her.

Charly was the first American Idol contestant to motivate me to get off of my couch and actually vote! I hope gets a record deal, because I'd buy her album and go to concert in a heartbeat.

i'm giving him a 1 coz i cant give her a 0

Charly was ok. She had a nice voice, but not American Idol material. Actually, I think almost everybody that was in the Final 32, could've had a good chance in the top 12, I mean, look at some of the ones that are there now.

yer it was orrite not my cup of tea but you know it wasnt bad she had a good voice but not quite good enough

She has a great voice and she is a an absolute doll, would of liked to see her in the Top 12... She is the cutest, prettiest contestant, & I love to hear to her talk, what a sweety.. If anyone know her tell her that I would love a date!!! ;~)

I thought she was going to do well untill her last performance :(