ok but not asnice as my english girlfriend called KATIE WEBBER

AWFUL AWFUL AWFUL

A great performer with an okay voice. She said she knows she does not have a powervoice but she knows how to use it. And I agree, she did a great job. But this is American Idol, you need to have an outstanding voice to win this.

I've seen her dance!! She's terrific!She's multi-talented,dancing, singing, spunky personality, and gorgeous to boot. Please keep it up Katie!! From one of your secret fans.

Katie is Very,very sexy..I love her very much

Give me an B, give me a Y, give me an E...Bye, bye, we donot need another dumb blond in showbiz.

I thought she wasn't as bad as the judges felt she was, she was bold and had a certain quality in her voice that might have led somewhere if she had more time to show us what she could do

Katie you were so great I stood up and applauded after that jazz number You are so beautiful you should be there instead of Fantasia she is just another Macy Gray Good luck in the future Katie

She was decent looking, except for her wierd nose, but she really couldn't sing all that well.

good... leah lebelle took her slot in the finals

loved the Jazz song the other was ok and i think your looks made you more popular coz you had an average voice

Katie you are soooooooooooo talented and as an added perk, beautiful and just a doll. Your dance number just floored me. I wish we had seen more of you. I will be looking out for a CD or Video of you. You got IT.

one ugly girl with the makeup off, yikes!

Just ok for me.

Katie was ok, but I don't think she could be and American Idol. Just a good singer.

I thought Katie's performance was GREAT ! Keep it up Katie - you've got talent, and my vote. You are my American Idol ! Love ya ! ! kwfan2

I liked her first song but not her wildcard song.

KATIE IS AWESOME AND SHOULD BE IN THE TOP 12!!!!!!! I LOVE YOU KATIE!