He wasnt a great singer. But i thought i saw him on one life to live could somebody please confirm is that true.

I just did not care for his voice and I don't think he knows how to use his voice. His performances were boring and he did not connect with most of the audience.

walking in memphis was amazing !

Came close to making the top 10. But I think that Matthew needs to get out there in the music scene. He could do a rock album if he wanted to--he has the voice for it. He kind of recalls Richard Marx or Bryan Adams in some places. Good-looking fellow with the face that will made the ladies swoon! Matthew, don't apply for American Idol again, get yourself on a record label soon and get that music career going!

Matt is a babe and I would very much like to see him put out a CD.

Cute to look at, but not quite enough talent to make it very far.

CUTE GUY...He is Clay Aikens boyfriend.

he is sooooooo sexy! he should model! sing ....model...whatever! just as long as I still get to see his beautiful smile!

Hot guy...they should put more good looking guys on idol, not FATSOs and UGLY people, I bump into a lot of these already on the streets I need not see more of them on TV.

I'd buy his Cd just so I could lick at... I mean LOOK AT ... the cover. And the guy sings way better than any contestant named JOHN so give me a freakin break about him not making the Top 12!

talk about no vocal talent...

Very, very overrated. The judges made it very obvious that they weren't nearly as intrigued by his vocal prowess as they were by his good looks.(which incidentally I don't see) Very glad he didn't make it to the finals, although he is better than a couple of the top 12

Can you say HOT? I think he could still have a good career in music if he wanted it. Loved his Walking in Memphis.

Man, I could kiss that adorable face forever!

his voice is sooo great it melts me....i want to meet matt sooo much and i hope i meet him someday in person!!!! I LOVE YOU!!!!

good... not good enough

alright voice, the girls loved him which is good 4 him but the voice wasnt terrific thats why he didnt get voted in

I want to see more of him! I hope he continues in the entertainment business because he is a star!

I liked this guy. He had a great stage presence..and I thought he had a voice for rock myself.

He is very cute and he seems like a nice person. his voice was nice but not really stand out. he came close, but did not make the final 12.

I love Matthew!!!!

TERIBLE!! that's all I have to say!

His voice melts me along with his smile of course..:)