A jerk indeed, but absolutely terrifying at the plate, and should have won the '95 MVP over Mo Vaughn rather handily. Injuries and his horrible reputation will probably keep him out of the Hall, but the guy was a force to be reckoned with in the 90's.

A three-alarm jerk, but at his peak, the guy was close to great. Career cut short by injury, or his numbers would likely have been pretty impressive.

Definitely not a personable guy, but he was a great hitter. If he was a nice guy or if he played longer, he would be a 5, but since he did have an injury that cut his career short, and was an a-hole, he can't be considered the best.