The funny thing is that some of these top contestants are not all-star material: Eliza(the paranoid Jennifer Wilbanks), Poverty (the STD whore), James(oaf who forgot to use both of his immunity idols),and Cirie(annoying Tickle me Elmo doll with a sense of entitlement ).   Reunite top contestants in an All-Star 'Survivor.' Translation=CBS's running out of ideas and too lazy to recruit new actors.

I would love to see another all stars version...with each season new "stars" emerge.

Didn't they do this, and didn't it stink on ice even worse than usual?

They are doing this next season anyway. If I could have 2 contestants from every season so far. It would be as follows. Colleen + Greg . Elisabeth + Rodger. Kelly+ KimP . Neleh and Paschal. Penny +Jed . Heidi and Ryan . I don't know much about the current one yet to decide on that.

It would be interesting to see if the previous contestants went about playing the game differently, and also to see who emerges as the leader among this group. For example, you might suppose that say, Ethan, might win again, but with a different group of people, his approach of being nice and flying under the radar might not be as effective. Though we have met these personalities before, we've never seen them in this mix. Who knows, maybe even Jerri has a shot this time. (But then again, the univese might implode too....) :)

It will be so fabulous but come on they HAVE to have ROB CESTERINO! I'm dying for it but if Rob's not in it and they only have boring people like Hunter and Nelah I'm going to e so disapointed. Also I'd like to see Brandon and Christy again. It will be a whole different game of strategy and so interesting.

Vote for who we want to see.

Yes, Mark Burnett should give the losers a second chance. Here is my list: Lex, Shii Ann, Kathy, Boston Rob, Big Ted, T-bird, Ghandia, Silas, Helen, Rudy, Brandon,Clay, Kelly G,and Kelly W. It would fun to see these troublemakers again.

I think it would be very interesting to see how past survivors would fare with each other! Great Idea!

i think it's great to have a all star survivor because there are enemies and friends that will backstab each other. i will have the following members on it. survivor 1 Rich Rudy Susan colleen survivor 2 alicia tina colby jerri survivor 3 brandon ethan linda linsey survivor 4 vee sean pascal neleh survivor 5 shii ann robb ted ghandia instead of 16 it will be 20 castaways 10 per tribe and 52 days to determine the untimate survivor.

I'd rather watch Chico and The Man episodes on TV Land.

The best idea ever! I would love to see my favourite contestants from previous Survivors duke it out!

Don't care for this idea-- unless it was just a 1 hour special show. The people who have been on Survivor already either won or lost- I want to see new people for each series.

this is wonderful idea. I would love to see them duke it out... It would really prove (out of the winners already) who is the 'true' survivor.

This is a great idea. It would give people who were screwed over originally another shot they deserve. From the first one I'd pick Colleen, Gretchen, Rudy and Gervase or Sean. From the second one I'd pick Rodger, Elisabeth, Kel and Maralyn "Mad Dog," and from the third, I'd pick Clarence, Linda, Carl and Jessie. From "Marqueses" we've gotta see blonde cutie Gabe again, along with Hunter, Gina and Tammy. THere's no way in hell Richard would last past the first or second episode- his team would vote him off the first time they'd lose immunity. People don't want that pompous, fake SOB hanging around.

A celebrity Survivor would be interesting, but once your normal everyday person has gone through the process, I don't see how it would be any more interesting to see them go through it again. The *only* ways it could work is if they change the nature of the game the way MTV does with it's Real World/Road Rules challenges or if they just wait several more years so the contestants are a little older than they are now.

Boring. Being a top contestant would acutally be a negative thing in a reunion, because it makes one an instant target.

For me, it would all be worth it just to see Elisabeth again.

by the time this happens a new show will have come along and noone will care about survivor.

I think this is a great idea. Imagine all your favorite contestants participating together, and then one of them cutting throats and coming out on top. Who would it be? Would Rich make it to the top a second time around? Rudy? What about Colleen - the 1st season's adorable, laid-back girl who should have remained in the final three but messed up in an immunity challenge and was kicked off! Or what about some of your favorite contestants right now - like Elisabeth and Rodger. This would be the best Survivor yet!

Rudy will probably be dead by the time 'Survivor V - The Ultimate Survivor' gets around. I am just not a fan of the reunion thing (like the Real World /Road Rules challenges). You already get enough exposure to those contestants that ended up in the top 4 of their groups as is. I would like to see the next Survivor take place in Antarcyica though.

I would like to see the 2nd,3rd and 4th place winners from Survivor I,II,III, and IV make up Survivor V. The fourth person can be the audiences favorite chosen by a poll on the internet. In the example of Survivor I it would be Kelly,Rudy,Sue and example of favorite,Colleen.