biggestmikalah fan 04/03/2005
SHE SHOULD HAVE MADE IT INSTEAD OF LINDSAY OR NADIA!!!!!!!! GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO MIKALAH!!
Helpful
Funny
Agree
Disagree
Jazza 04/02/2005
not bad, not great, she's bearable but isn't worthy of the top 12, she got booted exactly where she should have
CherrySoda99 03/10/2005
It's a shame she didn't make it!I was kind of rooting for her, but I glad Mikalah made it too. THey were both good.
Critterlover 03/10/2005
Amanda does not have a very strong, capable voice...it sounds very thin with no power behind it and also, as Randy would say, pitchy. Pretty, but not an American Idol.
James76255 03/06/2005
A 3 for talent and a 5 for looks. She'll probably manage to hang around for awhile just because of the eye candy factor.
ledzep44 03/06/2005
Horrible singer.
Sharose 03/06/2005
She's ok. Her voice isn't really outstanding, but she is very pretty, so she's got that going for her
OrangeCharlie 03/04/2005
Needs to stop playing it safe. Just put it all out there and go for it.
Maomania 03/02/2005
I like her voice (and looks) but she still has to step up a little more and blow us away. I do think though that she has a lot of talent.
9 reviews! « Previous | Page of 1 | Next »
Sort by Newest Oldest Most helpful Least helpful Highest rated Lowest rated
