Should have stayed around longer . . .

amanda should make it instead!!

I think Lindsey is good but started to get a little bit sucky.I actually agree with the person below me she's to low toned singing high songs.

A mistake that shows that AI judges often make bad decisions. They seem to becomes enthralled with some people though, at first, then realize that they are awful. Lindsey is a sweet and pretty girl but her voice is too low toned to handle many different songs and music styles.

She does have one of the best voices, just never seemed to get a song that showed it. Much better singer than all of the guys, second only to Carrie overall.

Its a shame she got the boot this week but i feel she did have potential, just her worst performance and america didn't feel like forgiving her, possibly because the others are so talented and her performance didn't meet to standards, i still like her though, she is a classy girl

I play Lindsey Cardinale in a celebrity role playing game, so of course I'm a fan of her. She has a really unique voice that makes her stand out from the other contestants. But unfortunately she was booted off tonight. Good luck in the future Lindsey! I know you'll do great! I have faith in you! Make your dreams come true! You rock!

I love her voice, but like Simon said she does need to do something spectacular to stay in the competition. She has a unique voice with great style....but I think she is capable of far more than she is putting out.

Lindsey has a unique and wonderful voice. Her problem is that she does not have a style. Like all great performing artists, she needs to know what kind of music she is best suited for and what she most wants to do. Knock on Wood was totally wrong for her and that is why it didn't work. Unfortunately, she will not have enough time to come to know herself musically in the remaining few weeks of this competition.

I think Lindsey is good... You just need to pick a song that would showcase your voice because it has a unique tone and it sets u apart from the other contestants

HEr smokey voice is awesome. She's unique, and I think that will help her throughtout the competition. I'm glad they put her through.

Very boring, plain performances but I love her sultry voice and she needs to sing something to show it off. Come on Lindsey, I know you can do better...you have definitely got it in you.

She's a Louisiana Girl! And I'm backing her all the way. Lindsey, if you read this, PLEASE Do something VERY MAGICAL in your next performance. Get alone by YOURSELF for a little while. REMEMBER WHO you are. WHAT DO YOU LOOOOVVVVEEE to sing the most. Come on out next week and KNOCK THE USA's SOCKS OFF!!!!!!!!!!!! We love you!!!!!!!!!!

She seems good, or maybe that's just because she's hot.

Another one that I can't decide if I like or not. Good voice that might have stood out more any other year. Good looking though, I'll certainly give her that.

I hate all these southern girls they picked up this season, they're SO boring cause all they sing is country.

She yet has to show us what she has. She did a pretty good performance this week, but she is still kinda safe with her performances. Blow us away girl.