JP gets Five Stars for being a Tulane Greenie. He's a good kid who wants to be successful. Unfortunately he's having a difficult season as a QB. More downs than ups. He still can be a good one though.

I see that my rating for Kelly Holcomb is a 3, and Losman couldn't even keep his job away from him. Therefore Losman needs to be qualified as a bad quarterback.

Kelly Holcomb is way better. Losman has thrown 4 TDs and 4 INTs, completing about 50% of his passes in his short career, and hasn't really shown the decision making skills I'd look for in a QB. He might develop into a decent starter in a few years, but don't rush it. He got pulled from being a starter for a reason.